December 11, 2024 2 Comment

A Potential Shift in the U.S. Economy

Advertisements

The American job market has often been described using terms like stability, resilience, and strength over the past yearHowever, speculation is growing that the landscape may shift drastically by 2025.

As we look forward to 2024, a noticeable deceleration in employment growth appears to be taking shape, slowing to a pace reminiscent of the job creation rates seen between 2010 and 2019. As of November, the economy was adding around 180,000 jobs monthly, with the unemployment rate experiencing a slight increase but remaining near historic lows.

This data tends to bolster confidence, leading the market to believe that the U.Seconomy is navigating a "soft landing," successfully curbing inflation without plunging into a recessionThe extent to which this trend continues into December will be clarified with the release of the final non-farm payroll report for 2024 by the U.SBureau of Labor Statistics, which is set to be announced at 9:30 PM Beijing time on Friday.

Economists anticipate that job growth for the prior month will be steady but uneventful, projecting an addition of around 160,000 non-farm jobs, with the unemployment rate expected to remain unchanged at 4.2%. Nela Richardson, Chief Economist at ADP, remarked that 2024 will showcase a very stable labor market, marking the first occurrence of supply-demand balance since the pandemic.

Even though the narrative surrounding the job market has revolved around stability and robustness, there is a broad consensus that 2025 could present a different set of challenges

Richardson cautioned, “I don’t expect us to maintain this stabilityEconomies can change very quickly.”

In recent months, the usual fluidity associated with a healthy labor market has begun to falter: hiring activity has hit a decade-low, with more workers choosing to stay put and prolonged job searches becoming increasingly commonCory Stahle, an economist with Indeed Hiring Lab, expressed that the situation remains relatively healthy but is experiencing considerable polarization, heavily influenced by specific industries or occupations.

Several factors are contributing to this slowdown and hesitance within the labor market, including the normalization that has followed the pandemic, employment growth driven by only a few sectors, high-interest rates, technological advances, and widespread uncertainty concerning the economic direction, global events, and potential U.S

policies.

What do recent employment figures reveal? Multiple indicators this week have indicated that while the U.Slabor market is experiencing cooling, it remains stable overall.

The much-anticipated ADP report highlighted a “slower” employment growth in December, indicating that employers added approximately 122,000 jobs, a drop from the 146,000 private sector net job additions reported in NovemberFurthermore, wage growth for those remaining in their positions has slowed to 4.6%, marking the slowest growth rate since July 2021.

Richardson noted that despite the significant deceleration in job growth, the broader labor market does not seem to be in a state of decline, attributing this partially to low layoff levels and voluntary departuresThe latest data on labor turnover, released earlier in the week, illustrated that resignation rates are at their lowest since the peak of the pandemic.

Additionally, newly released data indicated that layoffs in December decreased from the previous month, although they remain high compared to last year

According to a new report by Challenger, Gray & Christmas, American employers announced 38,792 layoffs in December, which represents a 33% decrease from November's figuresFor the entirety of 2024, the number of announced layoffs reached 761,358, marking the highest level since 2009.

Andrew Challenger, the firm’s senior vice president, stated that due to rapid technological advancements and changing economic environments, companies faced extraordinary changes in 2024. He added that many employers expect the advent of a new government will introduce further uncertainty, which is likely to lead to a moderation in hiring and an increase in layoffs in the short term.

The Department of Labor’s recent data reflected a decrease in initial jobless claims to 201,000 last week, the lowest total since February 2024. However, continued claims for unemployment benefits approached a three-year high, indicating an extended period is needed for unemployed individuals to secure new positions

alefox

It's essential to keep in mind that jobless claims data can experience volatility, particularly around holiday seasons, and is often subject to revisions.

Which industries face the most headwinds? In the coming months, several pivotal questions remain, particularly concerning the impacts of U.Strade, immigration, taxation, and fiscal policiesThese could bolster certain industries while severely undermining others.

Ellis Gould, a senior economist at the Economic Policy Institute, remarked that the labor market does not exist in a vacuum, noting that indicators such as wage growth, high employment population ratios, and low unemployment rates suggest a strong position—unless substantial policy changes occur, this status is unlikely to shift significantly.

She added that the new government seems primed to alter several policies, potentially leading to weaknesses in some economic sectors

Fellow economists have echoed Gould's warning, citing that policies such as stringent tariffs, mass deportation of undocumented immigrants, and the commitment to “downsize the government” could exacerbate inflation and raise living costsIf these policies come to fruition, sectors like agriculture, healthcare, food services, childcare, and construction could be hit hard with staffing shortages while significantly hampering public service agencies.

It’s important to underline that some of the sectors currently experiencing challenges have been responsible for most of the job growth over the past yearData from the Bureau of Labor Statistics indicate that between January and November, the private healthcare and social assistance sectors accounted for a staggering 75% of overall job growth: healthcare at 41%, government at 21%, and leisure and hospitality at 13%. Economists have voiced concerns over the concentrated job gains within these three sectors, citing early indications that they may be experiencing a loss of momentum.

In their outlook reports, economists have suggested that as hiring within these sectors returns to pre-pandemic levels, job growth is likely to slow down and could weaken further if employment promises are realized.

On a more optimistic note, Julia Pollak, Chief Economist at ZipRecruiter, expressed significant optimism regarding further improvements in the labor market this year

She posited that the increase in job opportunities seen in November may signal the beginnings of improvement in hiring for 2025. Pollak articulated that a primary reason for optimism this year is the Federal Reserve's decision to begin lowering interest rates in 2024. With a lagged effect of monetary policy, the three rate cuts so far are still gradually influencing the economy, with potentially more cuts on the horizon.

Pollak added, “The number of banks willing to lend to consumers is steadily increasing, various retail outlook surveys indicate improving performance among retailers, and metrics such as vehicle sales show that reduced borrowing costs are markedly improving consumers' affordability, catalyzing sales and activity.”

She cautioned that while the ripples from the labor market improvements might be slightly delayed, businesses are keen to ensure that sales growth is sustainable before increasing their workforce

“However, the more sustained these improvements are, the greater the likelihood of a rebound in the labor market,” she emphasized.

Moreover, she highlighted that hiring activities within the financial sector are accelerating in response to recent optimistic market performances and the anticipation of relaxed trading regulationsDespite the incoming government's focus on enhancing efficiency, growth in government sector employment is likely to persist.

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, job growth within the government sector predominantly occurs at the state and local levels, accounting for 12.3% and 6.6% of total employment growth, while federal employment makes up just 2%.

She concluded, “A significant portion of this growth is seen in states like Texas, Florida, and Nevada, where growth reflects the rising population… When a region experiences a surge in births, this results in a higher demand for public school teachers; similarly, with an influx of businesses, tax revenues, and population movements, more police officers are needed

Share:

Leave A Comment